Two-Dimensional Dancing

Amanda Thai, Junior undergraduate majoring in Anthropology and Gender Studies, NYU.
Coaxing the Spirits to Dance is an exhibition of Papuan Gulf art displayed at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The exhibition is ensconced in the Arts of Africa, Oceania, and the Americas gallery on the first floor, as a cool grey box amongst the relatively chaotic three-dimensionality of the gallery itself. The main emphasis of the display is the masks, boards and objects collected from Papua New Guinea, kept in glass cases and complimented with text below and photographs. This choice of representation sets the atmosphere of the exhibit, and reveals the contrasting nature between the exhibit and the pieces on display.
IMGP4027.JPG
There are five cultural groups from the Gulf province represented: the Elema speaking group in the east, the Purari Delta group, the Urama Islanders, the Era River group, and the Kerawa group in the west which includes Goaribari Island. However, these groups so distinctly identified in the opening paragraph are grouped together in the exhibit, with glass cases showing spirit boards from multiple groups right next to each other. The photographs below the cases pictures examples of the objects above. This manner of presenting the pieces indicates a belief in the importance of the broad function of the art object over the art object itself. In doing so, it simultaneously uproots these art objects from the subtle nuances of their own specific surroundings and groups them indiscriminately within the Margaret Meadian ethnographic present ‘Papuan Gulf’.
The use of photography also indicates this encompassing approach. The opening paragraph states that the “history of photography in Papuan Gulf essentially parallels that of sustained colonial contact, because it was primarily nonlocal visitors who made the photographs.” By using photographs in this exhibit to describe the objects displayed above them, and then further removing these objects from their specific cultural contexts creates a very colonizing view of the material. The supplementary text does not aid to refute this perception. The majority of texts focus on the photographers and their backgrounds more than they do the cultural significances of the objects themselves. While some highlight certain physical attributes of a certain piece, a casual browser of the exhibit leaves knowing more about the Western travelers who took the pictures and the techniques they used to do so instead of the importance of the objects on display.


One of the many photographs in the exhibit shows a man holding up two kakame – clan spirit statues. One of these statues is displayed behind the photograph, and an examination between the two indicates that the statue itself is lacking a loincloth present in the photograph. There is no additional explanation to the loincloth’s disappearance. The treatment of the kakame reveals the exhibit’s failure to accurately present the objects in their cultural contexts. A description of another photograph states that the photograph’s subject’s “personal ornament indicate that [the photograph’s subject] is probably a young girl.” As personal ornaments are used to distinguish the gender of the subject, the kakame’s ornamentation then, in the shape of its loincloth could have much cultural significance as well. The lack of a loincloth may mean something entirely difference from the presence of a loincloth. Unfortunately, a visitor would never know if this was the case. The exhibit instead chooses to mention that the man holding the two statues in the photograph remains unnamed – peculiar because the photographer usually lists the names of his friends. Nothing is said of either kakame or its significance.
However, the kakame is only one piece of the exhibit. The glass cases that dominate the space characterize the inadequateness of the presentation to fully appreciate the nature and form of the objects. Many of the pieces set in the glass cases are masks or items with ritual significance. The back wall of the exhibit displays two boards, both with holes or ledges on the bottom used as holds for holders to “raise above their heads” during dances. As the title of the exhibit indicates, these items are intended to move with dancers in rituals ‘coaxing the spirits to dance’. Their creators embodied spirits within the form of the objects themselves, and these spirits lived through the shape and lines of the object. Footage of four keveke dancers at Kinomere Island shows the way these objects are meant to be used and perceived in their cultures. The objects are meant to be experienced, not only viewed. Taken out of context and placed in within glass cases, visitors of the exhibit are barred from ever experiencing these objects in the way they are originally intended to be experienced. The glass boxes distance the viewers from these objects in an alien way from how these objects are meant to interact with its surroundings, and doing so actually changes the nature of the objects themselves. These objects on the Papuan Gulf had a spiritual life, ever-changing as dancers carry them through multiple dances and rituals. As soon as they are locked in cool, sterile glass cases, the very nature of the objects change from metaphysical spirits to the bounded lines and contours of high art.
While the exhibit treats these objects with utmost respect – each object carefully labeled and catalogued, the exhibit respects these objects as Western art, in ways that Western art should be respected, rather than as Papuan objects. Even the labels are Western oriented, as they do not describe the maker or purpose of the object, but rather the Western photographer and the history of the photograph. Text accompanying the footage of keveke dancers described the documenter, James Francis Hurley being admonished for rearranging scenes for a more dramatic shot, yet that he “officially collected objects and photographed places that no longer survive in any other way.” The text perfectly describes what the exhibit actually does if it does not allow the visitor to fully comprehend Papuan Gulf objects as such, and that is to allow reflection on the Western societies that have visited the Papuan Gulf. Did the objects really survive, if they are eventually rearranged and displayed as Western art is displayed?
Coaxing the Spirits to Dance at the Metropolitan Museum of Art reaffirms a familiar concept in Western mentalities of art as paintings and sculptures. Once created, art is immovable and frameable. Art is easily captured in a single photograph and hung up neatly on walls. Art is collected and institutionalized. The objects in the exhibit, once installed become these western art pieces and are forced to conform to what is acceptable as art by Western art institutions. They are no longer worn or used by participants but observed distantly by observers. The glass separating the masks and shields of the Papuan Gulf from the audience is physical evidence of this break, and the photographs are legacy of the change these objects underwent in the translation. A description of the exhibit by the Metropolitan Museum of Art writes of “historical photographs” within the exhibit. Viewing the exhibit itself, one must ask the question of whose history do these photographs embody? Surely, the history of the Papuan Gulf is not the main focus here, and one would have to coax a lot harder for the spirits to truly dance.
Works Cited

  • 2007. Coaxing the Spirits to Dance: Art of the Papuan Gulf. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Download PDF

2 Responses to Two-Dimensional Dancing

  1. Graeme Were April 10, 2007 at 5:17 am #

    An interesting review that raises some very important questions in curatorial practice. Two recent exhibitions in the UK that attempt to subvert the western gaze are Liverpool’s World Museum Pacific display and Cambridge’s Sepik temporary exhibition. Designers at Liverpool used special glass to display malanggan sculptures (New Ireland, PNG) – visitors can only see the objects when approaching from a specific angle, so as it glimpse them. Andrew Moutu, the curator of Paired Brothers at Cambridge – and curator of anthropology from PNG’s National Museum, went one step further by using black muslin to veil an object originally kept in a men’s house, as well as setting up the entire display as a system of pairs.
    What is also concerning about Melanesian exhibitions in western museums is the lack of engagement with source communities. This ought to be part and parcel of good curatorial practice today. Recent exhibitions at the British Museum, the Horniman and Cuming now underline the importance of collaboration as an interpretative process.

  2. Haidy Geismar, NYU April 12, 2007 at 9:34 am #

    I think that there was good consultation with source communities during the research for this exhibition even if it does not come across at all in the exhibition display. On 20 May, the Metropolitan is holding a symposium where many of the key researchers from the US and PNG will convene to discuss the exhibition, including Sebastian Haraha and Kaia Rove from the National Museum of Port Moresby who have now been brought over from PNG twice to work on this project:
    Coaxing the Spirits to Dance:
    Art of the Papuan Gulf
    Noted scholars present a series of lectures about the traditional sculpture of the Papuan Gulf and the photographs that chronicle it. Topics include new discoveries about the Museum’s rare photographs, the ways in which these images form visual biographies of the objects,
    and how they expand our knowledge of the history of art and photography in the Pacific.
    LECTURES
    10:30 Welcome and Introductory Remarks
    His Excellency Evan J. Paki, Ambassador of Papua New Guinea to
    the United States of America
    11:00 Art Forms across the Papuan Gulf
    Robert L. Welsch, Visiting Professor of Anthropology, Dartmouth College, and Adjunct Curator of Anthropology, The Field Museum
    11:30 Papuan Gulf Art and the National Museum
    Sebastine Haraha, Senior Technical Officer, Department of Anthropology,
    National Museum and Art Gallery of Papua New Guinea
    12:00 Break for lunch
    1:30 In Situ: Photographs of Art in the Papuan Gulf
    Virginia-Lee Webb, Research Curator, Department of the Arts of Africa, Oceania, and the Americas, The Metropolitan Museum of Art
    2:00 Creating Images: Frank Hurley and the Australian Museum’s Collections
    from the Gulf of Papua
    Jim Specht, Senior Fellow, Australian Museum
    (Cont.)
    SYMPOSIUM (cont.)
    FILM
    2:30 The Mythic Camera of Frank Hurley (2004)
    Directed by Simon Nasht (53 min.)
    LECTURES
    3:30 A Century After Outsiders Came to Visit: Life in the Purari Delta Today
    Kaia Rove, Local Level Government Councillor of Ward 14, Baimuru District,
    Gulf Province, Papua New Guinea
    4:00 Canoes, Carvings, and the Ancestors: Fluid Forms of the Purari Delta of
    Papua New Guinea
    Joshua A. Bell, Lecturer in Arts of the Pacific, Sainsbury Research Unit for
    the Arts of Africa, Oceania and the Americas, University of East Anglia
    Free with Museum admission; tickets and reservations are not required. For more information, please consult the Museum’s online Calendar at www.metmuseum.org,
    call (212) 396-5460, or contact lectures@metmuseum.org.
    This symposium is made possible by The Billy Rose Foundation, Inc.
    Programs occur in The Grace Rainey Rogers Auditorium, The Metropolitan Museum of Art,
    1000 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes

%d bloggers like this: